Direct Answer
On what grounds do you claim "leading efficiency"? The benchmarking needs two values — the industry "advanced value (benchmark)" and the "access/baseline value" — sourced from the national/industry energy-consumption limit standards and the benchmarking guides — compare your SEC with them: near the access line means a key retrofit target, close to the benchmark is where "leading" begins — benchmarking is not a self-evaluation but measuring yourself with an external ruler.
A scenario: A company claims its energy saving is good and asks what level it is in the industry — nobody can answer — without a reference, "good" has no definition. The logic is that "leading efficiency" is not a self-feeling but the result of comparing with external values — without the benchmark value, there is no leading — the first step of benchmarking is finding that external ruler.
1. What Benchmarking Is and Why an External Reference Is Needed
The definition of benchmarking — comparing the energy indicator (SEC) of the enterprise with the industry benchmark and access values: finding the gap and setting the target; The value of the external reference — the vertical self-comparison only sees "getting better": the horizontal external comparison sees "what level the enterprise is in the industry"; The objects of benchmarking — the advanced value (benchmark), the access/baseline value and the historical best: three references, three uses; The frequency of benchmarking — periodic benchmarking (quarterly/annual): the efficiency is dynamic and the benchmark also changes.
In one sentence: the vertical comparison answers "have I improved" and the horizontal benchmarking answers "am I leading" — leading efficiency must have an external reference — a self-evaluation does not count.
The comparison table of the reference objects:
| Reference | Answers what | Use |
|---|---|---|
| Advanced value (benchmark) | How well the best can do | Catch-up target |
| Access/baseline value | The worst allowed | Compliance bottom line |
| Historical best | How well I did myself | Self baseline |
| Industry average | Where the middle is | Positioning reference |
The premise of benchmarking — the SEC basis of the enterprise must match the benchmark basis (the boundary and output basis of KD-0395) — without an aligned basis, the benchmarking is a wrong comparison. An example: A company uses 5,000,000 kWh a year with an SEC of 10 kWh/piece — vertically it dropped 8% from last year — horizontally the advanced value is 7 — it finds itself in the middle — the improvement target changes from "better than last year" to "close to the benchmark". The logic is that the vertical is the process and the horizontal is the positioning — only the horizontal benchmarking tells what the 8% progress means in the industry — the target comes from it.
2. The Difference between the Benchmark, the Advanced and the Access Values
The advanced value (benchmark) — the advanced level of the industry: the average of the best enterprises — the "catch-up target"; The access value (baseline) — the access line of the industry: below it means restriction or rectification — the "compliance bottom line"; The average/baseline value — the average level of the industry: the reference of the middle — the "positioning reference"; The relation of the three — access < average < advanced: falling into different intervals means different situations.
In one sentence: the three values are three ticks on one line — the access is the bottom line, the average is the positioning and the advanced is the target — by the three ticks, the enterprise sees its place at a glance.
An example: An industry: the access value 12, the average 10 and the advanced 8 — an enterprise has 11.5 — near the access line — it is a "key retrofit object", not "leading efficiency". The logic is that the three ticks divide the enterprises into three grades — near the access = a key retrofit object, close to the average = the middle and close to the advanced = where leading begins — with clear ticks, the positioning is unambiguous.
3. The Data Sources: the Energy-Consumption Limit Standards and the Benchmarking Guides
Source one: the limit standard — national/industry standards: giving the access and advanced values, some giving the limit value — the most authoritative baseline; Source two: the benchmarking guide — industry benchmarking guides/white papers: giving the benchmark value and the best practices — providing the advanced reference; Source three: the association data — the efficiency rankings/statistics published by the associations: supplementing the industry distribution; The check of the sources — the standard number, the issue year and the scope: with the right version and the right scope, the value is valid.
In one sentence: three sources — the limit standard gives the access and the limit, the guide gives the benchmark and the advanced and the association data gives the distribution — with the sources checked, the value is credible.
The check list of the data sources — is the standard number the latest version? Does the scope cover the product? Does the output basis match the standard? Is the statistical year of the benchmark value stated? — the four checks, the value is valid.
The timeliness of the sources — the limit standards are revised periodically: the old value expires after the new standard — benchmark with the latest version, otherwise the target is outdated. An example: A company looks up the values — first the access value in the limit standard, then the advanced value in the benchmarking guide and the industry distribution in the association data — the three sources assemble a complete reference — a fuller picture than one source only. The logic is that the reference is "assembled" — the access governs the compliance, the advanced governs the target and the distribution governs the positioning — without one of the three, the reference is incomplete.
4. How to Quantify the Gap with the Benchmark
The calculation of the gap — the gap rate = (SEC of the enterprise − the benchmark) ÷ the benchmark × 100%: how large the gap is, quantified at a glance; The decomposition of the gap — where the gap comes from: the output basis, the equipment efficiency and the management loss — decomposed to the links; The weight of the gap — look at the large-gap links first: the links with the large share are improved first — the improvement priority comes from it; The verification of the gap — confirm the basis consistency before the benchmarking: with different SEC bases, the gap is false.
In one sentence: the gap rate = (SEC − benchmark) ÷ benchmark — decompose the gap to the links, rank by the share and verify the basis first — only then the quantification is meaningful.
The decomposition steps of the gap — step one: calculate the total gap rate; step two: split the gap by the systems (how much the motor/air-con/lighting each account for); step three: rank by the share and mark the top three; step four: find the improvement action for each key link (VFD/sealing/tuning) — four steps, the gap becomes a plan.
The notes of the gap quantification — the output fluctuation: the output differs between the seasons and the SEC fluctuates naturally, benchmark with the same-period basis; the tariff influence: the price change does not affect the SEC (SEC is energy not money), do not mix; the basis drift: when the boundary or the output basis changes, recalculate the gap — the three notes, the quantification stays true. An example: An enterprise has an SEC of 10 and a benchmark of 8 — the gap rate = (10 − 8) ÷ 8 = 25% — decomposed: the motor system accounts for 60%, the air-con 25% and the lighting 15% — the improvement priority: the motor first, the air-con next and the lighting last. The logic is that the quantified gap must be decomposed — 25% is the total and the shares of the links are the path — improving the large-share links first closes the gap fast.
5. How to Turn the Benchmarking Result into the Improvement Target
The setting of the target — the short-term target: first to the average; the mid-term target: then closer to the advanced — approaching in stages; The decomposition of the target — the annual SEC target → the quarterly milestones → the link actions: the big target is broken into executable actions; The tracking of the target — check the SEC and the gap change against the benchmark monthly: the improvement effect is visible; The loop of the target — after reaching it, update the benchmark (the advanced value is improving): the benchmarking is not one-time.
In one sentence: the result becomes the target in three steps — set the grade first (to the average/to the advanced), decompose next (annual to quarterly to links) and track after (the gap narrowing monthly) — after reaching it, change to a new benchmark.
The example table of the target decomposition:
| Stage | Target | Action |
|---|---|---|
| First quarter | SEC to 11 | Motor VFD retrofit starts |
| Third quarter | SEC to 10.5 | Compressor sealing done |
| Second year | SEC to 9.5 | Air-con optimization |
| Third year | SEC to 8.5 (near benchmark) | Full advanced benchmarking |
The verifiability of the target — each stage has a number, an action and an acceptance (measured SEC) — the target is not a slogan but a measurable milestone. An example: After the benchmarking, an enterprise sets the target — year one: SEC from 11.5 to 10 (to the average) — year two: to 9 (closer to the advanced 8) — the gap rate is tracked monthly: from 43% narrowing to 12% — after two years, the benchmark is updated for a new target. The logic is that the target must be "staged and trackable" — one step to the benchmark is unrealistic and without milestones nothing is executable — watching the gap narrow monthly lands the improvement.
Back to the digital electrical intelligent supervision system — the digital tools of the benchmarking: the platform calculates the SEC of each workshop monthly (unified basis), embeds the industry benchmark and access values and automatically marks "inside or outside the line" — the benchmarking changes from "checking the standard and calculating the gap" to "the platform reminding the gap automatically" — the monthly progress of SEC and the narrowing of the gap are seen in one chart.**
Scope and Limitations
- The conclusions in this article are intended for LV distribution and electrical-safety sites. Standard numbers (GB/T 2589) refer to their currently effective editions, and product parameters follow the latest FEXLINK selection handbook and product knowledge base.
- Quantitative criteria (protection zone, discharge and residual voltage, earth resistance, thresholds and grading) hold under the preconditions stated in this article. Where the site voltage level, earthing arrangement, environmental category or load profile differs, the figures must be recalculated.
- Specific product models and parameters are subject to the latest selection handbook and product knowledge base; this article does not constitute selection or procurement advice.
- Standard numbers cited here refer to the currently effective editions; when a standard is revised, the related quantitative conclusions must be re-checked.
- Deployment and implementation for specific projects must be carried out by qualified engineers based on site survey and design drawings.
Frequently Asked Questions
On What Grounds Do You Claim "Leading Efficiency"
The benchmarking needs two values — the industry "advanced value (benchmark)" and the "access/baseline value" — sourced from the national/industry